Saramsha

No. 066  ·  21 November 2026

A Rhythm Neither Note Is Playing

Two sine tones, a few hertz apart, playing at once. Neither one is pulsing — but together they are. Press play, then drag the slider toward the reference tone and listen for the pulse to slow down, the way a piano tuner chases two strings into agreement.

the two tones, close up

what you actually hear: loudness over the last few seconds

reference tone your tone combined loudness — the beat

About this piece

A wobble that isn't in either tone

Play 220 Hz and 224 Hz together and you do not hear two pitches a semitone's fraction apart. You hear one pitch, roughly in the middle, getting louder and quieter four times a second. That pulsing is called a beat, and it is not coming from either oscillator — it only exists because the two of them are present at once.

Add two sine waves of frequency fA and fB and a trigonometric identity rewrites the sum as a product:

sin(2πfAt) + sin(2πfBt) = 2 · cos(π·Δf·t) · sin(2π·favg·t)

where Δf = fA − fB and favg is their average. The second factor, sin(2π·f_avg·t), is a tone at roughly the average pitch — too fast to hear as a rhythm. The first factor, cos(π·Δf·t), is far slower, and it is not a pitch at all: it is an envelope, a loudness that rises and falls. Because loudness only cares about the size of the wave, not its sign, each half-cycle of that slow cosine reads as one pulse — so the number of beats you hear per second comes out to exactly |Δf|, the plain difference between the two frequencies. Nothing about the sign or the average matters. Two tones 4 Hz apart beat four times a second whether they sit at 220 and 224, or at 1,000 and 1,004.

How a piano actually gets tuned

A tuner rarely reads a frequency off a dial. They strike a reference and the string together and listen to the beat get slower as the string is brought into tune, until, at perfect agreement, the beat simply stops — Δf has reached zero and the two true pitches have become one. That is exactly what the "tune by ear" mode on this page asks you to do: no numbers, just the pulse, same as a real piano.

Where the beat stops being a beat

Push Δf past about 15–20 Hz and something changes: the pulses come too fast to count individually, and the ear's inner workings — specifically, a patch of the basilar membrane called a critical band — can no longer keep the two tones resolved as separate wobbling loudness. What you hear instead is a rough, buzzing dissonance, not a rhythm. It is the same physical beating the whole time; only the listener's resolution runs out. Slide the gap on this page past 15 Hz or so and you can catch that handoff happening yourself.

Both tones here are plain sine oscillators run through a soft compressor so the combined volume never spikes; nothing is recorded, uploaded, or sent anywhere. ?fb= sets your tone's starting frequency in hertz, ?mode=challenge opens straight into tune-by-ear, and ?play starts the audio (blocked by the browser until you interact with the page once).